← All articles
[BLOG] SEO

Spam links to your site: when to worry and when to disavow

Strange links to your site you never asked for? How Google treats spam backlinks, when the Disavow tool is really needed and how to use it safely.

PUBLISHED
READING TIME
7 min
TOPIC
SEO
VERSION
v1.0
IN THIS ARTICLE · 9 PARTS
  1. 01Why spam links point to your site at all
  2. 02What Google does with them
  3. 03When you really need to act
  4. 04How to check your links for free
  5. 05If you have a manual action: step by step
  6. 06How the disavow file looks
  7. 07Mistakes that do more harm than the spam
  8. 08What actually raises your authority
  9. 09Sources

Sooner or later every site owner opens a backlink tool and sees it: hundreds of links from sites with odd names, foreign languages and pages that look like nobody reads them. Some tools even colour them red and call them "toxic". The short answer: for most sites this is normal and needs no action. Google says most sites will never need the Disavow tool [1], and its systems neutralise spam links on their own [2]. You act only in two cases: when Search Console shows a manual action for unnatural links, or when you know that someone (you or a previous agency) bought or built links to rank.

This article belongs with what domain authority is and how to raise it. If you want the full picture of links and authority scores, see domain authority: a complete guide.

You did not ask for them, and that is usually the point: nobody did. The most common sources are:

  • Scraper sites that copy pages from across the web, links included, to fill themselves with content.
  • Automatic directories and "statistics" sites that list every domain they find, with a value estimate, a screenshot and a link.
  • Comment and forum spam from bots, where your address sometimes ends up by accident.
  • Old link packages that a previous agency or freelancer bought "for SEO", which you may not even know about.

Only the last one is a real problem, because it is the only one that was created to manipulate rankings. Google defines link spam exactly by that purpose: links created "primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings" [3].

What Google does with them

Google has been dealing with spam links for more than a decade. In 2016 the Penguin algorithm became part of the core algorithm and started to devalue spam links instead of pushing down the whole site [4]. In 2022 Google announced that SpamBrain, its AI-based spam prevention system, now neutralises the impact of unnatural links, and that any credit those links passed is lost [2].

In plain words: a random spam link usually does not help you and does not hurt you. It simply does not count.

The red "toxic" label in an SEO tool is that tool's own estimate, not a Google verdict. Google does not publish a toxicity score and does not ask you to clean up every odd link.

When you really need to act

Google's own rule for the Disavow tool is clear: use it only if both are true [1]:

  1. You have a considerable number of spammy, artificial or low-quality links pointing to your site, and
  2. those links have caused a manual action, or likely will cause one.

The second condition is the key. In practice, it covers two situations:

  • You have a manual action. In Search Console, under Security & Manual Actions, the Manual actions report says "Unnatural links to your site" [5]. If you see a green tick there, you have no manual action.
  • You know links were bought. For example, an earlier agency sold you "100 links from strong sites", or you paid for articles with links that pass ranking credit. Google's rules list buying links, excessive link exchanges, automated links and paid articles with links as spam [3].
What you seeWhat it meansWhat to do
Hundreds of links from odd foreign sitesScrapers and directories, normal noiseNothing
A tool marks links as "toxic"The tool's estimate, not Google'sNothing, unless one of the cases below applies
Your rankings dropped and you see spam linksUsually a coincidence; look for other causes firstCheck Search Console, content and competitors
You know links were bought in the pastA real risk of a manual actionRemove what you can, disavow the rest
A manual action for "Unnatural links to your site"Google has penalised part or all of the siteClean up, disavow, request a review
  1. Search Console, the Links report. Open "Links" in the left menu. "Top linking sites" shows which domains link to you most. This is Google's own list, so start here. If you have not set up Search Console yet: Google Search Console for beginners.
  2. Search Console, Manual actions. One click, and you know whether there is a real problem at all [5].
  3. A free backlink checker. Ahrefs and Moz have free versions that show more links than Search Console, with their own scores. Useful for comparison, but remember that their colours and scores are theirs.

Look for patterns, not single links: dozens of links with the exact same keyword as the link text, links from sites selling "guest posts", or a sudden jump in new links that you cannot explain.

If you have a manual action: step by step

Google describes the process in the Manual actions report help page [5]. In short:

  1. Export your links from Search Console: "Top linking sites" > Export, or "Latest links" for the newest ones.
  2. Find the links that break the rules. If the list is long, start with the domains that link to you most and with links added in recent months.
  3. Ask for removal. Write to the site owners and ask them to remove the link or mark it rel="nofollow" or rel="sponsored". Keep a record of whom you wrote to and when.
  4. Disavow only what you could not remove. Google warns that blindly adding all backlinks to the disavow file is not a good-faith effort, and that you should not disavow natural links [5].
  5. Request a review from the Manual actions report, explaining what you removed and what you could not, with evidence.

Reviews usually take several days or weeks, and link-related requests can take longer [5].

How the disavow file looks

It is a plain text file (.txt, UTF-8), with one entry per line [1]. Three kinds of lines:

Line in the fileWhat it does
# Bought in 2024, removal requested, no answerA comment for you; Google ignores lines that start with #
domain:cheap-links-network.exampleDisavows every link from that domain and its subdomains
https://some-blog.example/paid-post.htmlDisavows the links from that one page only

Use domain: when one site links to you many times; it is simpler and catches the pages you have not found yet.

You upload the file through Google's Disavow links tool. Three things that catch people out [1]:

  • It does not work with a Domain property in Search Console, only with a URL-prefix property. If you only have a Domain property, add a URL-prefix one for your https:// address.
  • A new upload replaces the old list. If you had a file before, add to it rather than start a new one.
  • It takes a few weeks for Google to take the list into account.

Mistakes that do more harm than the spam

  • Disavowing everything a tool calls "toxic". Among those links there are often normal ones: local directories, partners, small blogs. Google writes that incorrect use can harm your site's performance in Search [1].
  • Paying for a "toxic link cleanup" without a manual action. It is money for a problem Google has already solved on its own.
  • Disavowing instead of removing. With a manual action, Google expects you to have tried removal first [5].
  • Panicking over "negative SEO". A competitor pointing spam links at you is a popular fear. For the vast majority of sites, these links are simply neutralised [2].

What actually raises your authority

Cleaning up links rarely moves you up. Earning real ones does: partners and suppliers, industry associations, local media, sponsorships and content others want to cite. The full list of 15 ways is in domain authority: a complete guide, and for the first steps with a new site, see new website? how to help it climb in Google faster.

Sources

  1. Google Search Console Help. "Disavow links to your site." support.google.com
  2. Google Search Central Blog. "December 2022 link spam update releasing for Google Search." developers.google.com/search/blog
  3. Google Search Central. "Spam policies for Google web search." developers.google.com/search
  4. Google Search Central Blog. "Penguin is now part of our core algorithm" (2016). developers.google.com/search/blog
  5. Google Search Console Help. "Manual actions report." support.google.com

More from the blog

All articles →